In a new lawsuit, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission and 22 states allege that Amazon engaged in misleading and fraudulent practices that impacted about a million SMBs. Amazon denies the allegations, framing its moves as routine and aligned with standard practices in search-ad bid marketplaces.
So what’s going on here? Starting with the complaint, it alleges that Amazon secretly charged businesses more for advertising, specifically involving its bid marketplace. Ad formats in question include Sponsored Products ads, Sponsored Brands ads, and display ads that run alongside its search results.
To understand the lawsuit requires stepping back for some definitional context. At the heart of all of this is the difference between first-price and second-price auctions. The latter is what Amazon has done for years, where a winning bid for an ad placement doesn’t pay its bid but a penny over the second-highest.
As you can probably extrapolate, second-price auctions incentivize high bids, as the advertiser knows they probably won’t end up paying that price but rather a lesser price that’s a penny above the bid that they beat. But in 2019, the lawsuit alleges, Amazon surreptitiously changed the way these systems work.
Shill Shock
How did Amazon do this? The complaint alleges that it introduced a hidden surcharge, internally called a “soft reserve price.” This resembled what one internal document uncovered by the FTC called “invented auction participant.” This was essentially a fake bidder that increased the value of second-ranking bids.
The result, according to the lawsuit, was that about 80 percent of bidders ended up paying their actual bid price – effectively turning a second-price auction into a first-price auction, but in a roundabout way. The bottom line is that, if true, this manufactured higher prices paid by winning bids in any auction.
So what’s the damage? If the lawsuit’s allegations are on target (we can’t stress enough that these remain allegations until proven true), Amazon’s practices impacted more than 1 million brands and sellers – many of them SMBs, and may have generated tens of billions of incremental ad dollars.
To provide a sense of relative scale, Amazon’s ad revenues were $68 billion last year. So if additional ad dollars from the alleged practices resulted in “tens of billions” in revenue over about seven years, it’s a significant amount involving a public company in the highly competitive search ad world.
Reputational Hit
More significant than the dollar impact may be brand-trust impact. As noted, SMBs were operating under a specific second-price principle in their bidding behavior. If it turns out that Amazon manipulated that system without telling SMBs – or larger brands for that matter – it could take a costly reputational hit.
This all unfolds as Amazon ratchets up its SMB ad business through non-endemic approaches. Rather than just promoting products that are sold on Amazon – it’s traditional practice – it’s growing its addressable market by opening things up to local services that relate to Amazon product searches.
That growth into local services (think: ads for home services alongside searches for tools or other DIY fodder) could be diminished if the FTC and its fellow plaintiffs successfully prove their claims to be true. It’s hard enough to sell advertising products to SMBs… mistrust would be a deal breaker in this case.
As for Amazon’s response, it stated in a blog post that its auctions evaluate billions of bids so prices naturally vary, and advertisers are properly informed about the pricing systems. It called the lawsuit “misguided,” and says the complaint “fundamentally misunderstands how advertisers operate.”
We’ll keep an eye on this to see where it lands.
Header image credit: Rubaitul Azad on Unsplash


