How has local media and advertising changed the most over the past 25 years? It’s a heck of a lot more fragmented, says Joe Naylor. Now an advisor at 19Y Advisors, Naylor is a credible witness on this topic, given two decades in local media sales for giants such as Cox Media Group and E.W. Scripps.
“It was a lot easier to build and deliver product – both from an audience standpoint and from an ad product standpoint – 10 years ago,” he said on stage at Localogy’s L26 conference. “These days, with the plethora of different options that an advertiser might have, or different options an audience user might have, it’s all about trying to remain relevant in that very noisy space.”
So how does this transformation impact the traditional media giants that Naylor used to run with? And how are they adapting to all that change?
“Traditional media is romantic and focused on legacy practices in some cases,” said Naylor. “And since the revenue is still strong, it’s difficult to be ambidextrous and innovate at the same time you operate. That’s not an indictment, it’s more so a candid observation of what I’ve seen over the last 25 years.”
Legacy Practices
The result of this inaction has hurt media companies, as we’ve all seen. Though they still have several advantages in local ad markets, growth is usually seen with more agile and digitally-native companies. This is a familiar story over the past several years, but many media companies aren’t learning the lesson.
“Traditional media is losing relevancy,” said Naylor, “some at less of a rapid clip than others, because the innovation side is not keeping up with the operational side.”
This all boils down to a classic innovator’s dilemma, going back to Naylor’s comments about legacy practices. And when we look around these days, it is possible – though difficult – to overcome an innovator’s dilemma. Google is doing this as we speak, as it cannibalizes itself with AI search.
Closer to the traditional media world, there are other exemplars such as the New York Times Company. As we examined recently, its moves into subscription-based games (Wordle) and food (NYT Cooking) build on traditional strengths such as crosswords and food sections, respectively, in a modern way.
But all that said, traditional media isn’t dead. It still drives revenue, says Naylor. But that very factor makes it harder to cannibalize oneself with new innovations. When it comes to innovator’s dilemmas, gradual attrition is a silent killer, as opposed to sudden declines that spark necessity-driven innovation.
Lessons in Local Publishing: A Houston Chronicle Conversation
Spots and Dots
So what and where is the innovation required in traditional local media products and business models? The legacy model of “selling spots and dots” is antiquated. Conversely, one positive development Naylor pointed to is programmatic CTV advertising, such as that provided by Universal Ads.
Moves like these democratize traditional advertising and make it accessible to a long tail of SMBs. That opens up new market growth opportunities that weren’t there before, he says. But the name of the game will be to serve that new market without cannibalizing or diminishing core revenues on the premium end.
In other words, if CTV isn’t done right, it could be a race to the bottom, says Naylor, in terms of normalizing low-cost inventory. This could come about if competition drives discounted pricing across the board. It’s critical that publishers and broadcasters preserve premium inventory in the process.
“Our media companies need to figure out how to unlock value from more mass distribution of our inventory,” said Naylor, “while simultaneously driving value for the inventory that is not just spots and dots. What I mean by that is unique sponsorable content and activations using local talent.”
That last part is the unlock for traditional media companies to build new models on existing strengths. In fact, local media was the original creator economy, says Naylor. But traditional media has dropped the ball in terms of leveraging those local columnists, weathermen and personalities that carry cachet.
“I would love to see the utopia that’s a combination of democratized accessible inventory while driving really big demand and premiums for what should not be commoditized,” Naylor said. “The currency is becoming more accessible, but what we can do to remain relevant is still drive those premiums.”


